Welcome to Brooklyn Square Pizza
Brooklyn Square Pizza, located in Manalapan Township, NJ, is known for its authentic Sicilian-style pizza. Customers rave about the perfectly melted cheese, chunky sauce, and chewy yet slightly crisp dough that sets this pizza apart. With a variety of options like chicken Marsala and arancini, this spot is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere make it a great place for groups or a casual dinner. Whether you're a local or visiting from out of town, Brooklyn Square Pizza's delicious offerings are sure to leave a lasting impression. Highly recommended for a taste of Brooklyn in Jersey.
-
73 Wilson Ave Manalapan Township, NJ 07726 Hotline: (732) 851-7599
Welcome to the savory world of Brooklyn Square Pizza, where authenticity meets innovation in every square slice. Located at 73 Wilson Ave in Manalapan Township, NJ, this Italian pizza joint is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered.
Brooklyn Square Pizza offers a plethora of options that cater to every pizza lover's preferences. From classic Sicilian slices to mouth-watering chicken Marsala, this place has it all. Customers rave about the flavorful sauce, perfectly melted cheese, and the dough that strikes the right balance between crispiness and chewiness.
One diner described the upside-down Sicilian dine-in as a culinary masterpiece, praising the friendly service and cozy atmosphere. The menu not only boasts a variety of pizza options but also includes delicious Arancini and hearty salads for a well-rounded dining experience.
Whether you're a local looking for the best pizza in town or a visitor seeking a slice of Brooklyn in New Jersey, Brooklyn Square Pizza is the place to be. With its casual ambiance, friendly staff, and diverse menu offerings, this spot is perfect for groups, families, and solo diners alike.
So, if you find yourself craving a slice of authentic Brooklyn-style pizza, look no further than Brooklyn Square Pizza. With each bite, you'll taste the passion and dedication that goes into creating these delectable square pies.
Best pizza in Manalapan area. Service was fantastic and friendly. Arancini was huge and delicious.
You like Sicilian Pizza......then this is worth the drive to get!! This is by far the BEST Sicilian style pizza we have ever had. We live in Lakeland, FL, but when in town to visit family, this is one if our "Must Stops"!!
not pictured here but also had the pepperoni sicilian slice. That was really good. Also had the chicken caesar salad slice which wasn't bad either. Great pizza here
So this review is just for the upside down Sicilian dine-in, but, WOW, I LOVE this pizza! The sauce was awesome both flavor-wise and texturally (ever-so-slightly chunky, which I love), the cheese was perfectly melted, and that dough thoooooo. Very slight crisp on the bottom but overall doughy and chewy, which is EXACTLY what I like (but understand that's not everyone's preference). I love when there's some weight behind the dough and it's not just completely airy floof. Our server was also sooo friendly and even offered to move us to a larger table to help make the pizza not feel so crammed on our table even though we were just two people. A fair amount of seating inside, I would say maybe for 20ish people. It's a good thing we live so far away, otherwise, we'd probably be here once a week. Highly recommend!
I take this seriously. Absolutely the best chicken Marsala I have had in a restaurant. It hit that comfort space and I left feeling great. It came with a big salad, hot bread and spaghetti. I also bought a Nonna square pie for later and lunch. Would recommend this place all day long.
This is a great spot to grab a slice or two of pizza. They have a lot of options and my favorite was the nonnas and Margherita. They do have seating however I feel like it's more of a takeout and delivery spot.
Finally, made it!!! Saucy Sicilian slice is excellent! Worth the wait. They're from Brooklyn & the pizzas are damn near perfect. I love a saucy slice & this didn't disappoint. Not overly cheesy, faint Romano flavor. &3.75 finally see what all the fuss is about. A real treat made with love, very fresh, stand up crust, mace the Brooklyn way!
A guy was on social media telling me the square pizza at Brooklyn Square Manalapan is better than L&B Gardens. (Camera deadpans to my face) Better?! First, we're in Jersey and the place says Brooklyn. No shame in their game Second, how do you even say Manalapan?? I'm born and raised in Brooklyn. We invented things here! People have fond memories of Brooklyn and for me, L&B Spumoni Gardens is what I hold near and dear to my heart. Heading to the strip mall in Manalapan, I spot Brooklyn Square. I park in the back and walk inside. Just a typical pizza place that you'd find, well in Brooklyn. Jersey pizza, I have to be on guard. Jersey is famous for their "Bar pizza". It has a story, anything outside of New York is dopey to me so let them enjoy their nonsense. I go to the register and show the girl the social media picture. I'd like this slice please. Coming right up sir. I grab a nice Manhattan Soda and sit to enjoy my pizza. Alright! The pizza is good! Nice crust, the sauce isn't sweet or overpowering and the cheese is a high end blend. I hate a wet, sloppy pizza square. I have seen Dom from Difara take crust out of the pan with his bare hands. The Brooklyn-Manalapan pizza makers have the secret formula for Brooklyn pizza. Did you steal our water? Tell me!!!! Haha Listen, I'm not going to throw shade on L&B. Brooklyn Square Pizza makes a damn good slice of pizza in Manalapan. Keep your cardboard bar pizza New Jersey, make more squares.